Building a Scalable Influencer Program Across Four Brands

Influencer Marketing & Scalable Systems
Written By Alexis Melendez

Summary

When I joined Circle Line as Marketing Director, influencer partnerships were largely reactive. Although we received a steady stream of creator requests, we lacked the systems and resources to evaluate them efficiently, meaning many opportunities went unexplored.

I transformed that ad hoc process into a scalable influencer marketing program supporting four brands. I developed the application infrastructure, CRM workflow, approval process, contracts, tracking systems, and reporting framework that allowed the team to expand creator partnerships while reducing manual work. By 2025, the program generated $102,000+ in attributable revenue, 3 million+ views, and 213,000+ engagements, while becoming efficient enough to transition day-to-day management to my team.

The Challenge

Circle Line received a steady stream of creator requests, but we weren’t set up to take full advantage of them.

Requests arrived through emails, Instagram DMs, and contact forms with no consistent process for evaluating creators, managing communication, tracking deliverables, or measuring results. Because every partnership required significant manual effort, the team simply couldn’t accommodate as many collaborations as the opportunity warranted.

The challenge wasn’t finding influencers. It was building a scalable system that allowed us to increase the volume of quality partnerships, reduce administrative work, and clearly measure business impact.

Strategy

The biggest efficiency win was flipping the model from outbound to inbound. Instead of the team researching and pitching creators, I built a public-facing application on the Circle Line website where creators could apply directly, submitting their media kit, follower counts, platforms, and availability all in one place. That alone cut the time spent on initial research dramatically.

From there I built out the backend: a CRM workflow to review applications, a tiered approval process, a contract template, a promo code system tied to each creator so we could track actual ticket revenue, and a tracking spreadsheet that became the program's database across all four brands. By 2025 the program had enough structure that I could hand day-to-day management to my team while staying involved in high-value partnerships and strategic direction.

My Role

Program Design: Built the overall influencer program framework, establishing application requirements, partnership criteria, approval processes, contracts, and measurement standards across four brands.

Workflow & Systems: Designed the end-to-end operational workflow, including CRM routing, application review, tracking databases, promo codes, and reporting dashboards that reduced manual work and improved visibility into program performance.

Multi-Brand Management: Scaled the program across Circle Line, The Beast, North River Lobster Company, and La Barca Cantina, adapting partnership strategies while maintaining consistent operational processes.

Team Development: Documented processes and trained team members to manage day-to-day creator partnerships while continuing to oversee strategy, high-value collaborations, and program evolution.

Results

2024

128 Posts published across 4 brands

17.8M+ Combined follower reach

11.7M+ Total views

520K+ Total engagements

$48K Total program spend

2025

167 Posts published

21M+ Combined follower reach

3M+ Total views

213K+ Total engagements

$102K+ Revenue driven through promo codes

$28.9K Total program spend

What I Learned

Building a successful influencer program wasn’t about finding better creators. It was about building better systems.

When marketing relies entirely on manual effort, growth eventually stalls. By investing time in processes, documentation, and measurement, we created a program that could scale across multiple brands, produce meaningful business results, and continue operating without depending on one person. That experience reinforced one of my core leadership philosophies: the best marketing teams don’t just execute campaigns, they build systems that make great work repeatable.

Alexis Melendez

Marketing Leader | Brand Strategy · Integrated Marketing · Revenue Growth | Consumer, Experiential & Cultural Marketing

https://heyalexismelendez.com
Previous

Launching SUMMIT One Vanderbilt, New York’s Newest Observation Deck Experience
Next

Founding Circle Line's Pup Cruise Franchise